Open Shelf
New Jersey · Handmade · 5 shops

Stores in New Jersey That Buy Handmade

These 5 shops say they look for handmade, handcrafted or artisan-made work. All are in New Jersey; see all 301 nationwide.

The 5 shops

Princeton Junction

West Windsor Arts Artisan Gift Shop

Heads up: Three holiday shopping days are promotions inside the same consignment program.

EmailYear-round consignment term September 2026 to June 2027. Handmade by the artisan only + feesGiftsHomeJewelry
West Orange

West Orange Arts Council Gift Shoppe

Heads up: Commission % on inquiry.

EmailMembers-only gift shoppe showcasing one-of-a-kind local handmade art for consignment. Exact commission split not published on the Gift Shoppe page — confirm when you inquire. Boutique arts-council shop — not a vendor mall. By-appointment gallery/gift shop hours.ArtGiftsJewelry
Lawrence Township

Out of Step Offbeat Boutique & General Store

FormEmailMercer County boutique at Trenton Farmers Market carrying goods from ~175–300 artists, makers, and small businessesGiftsHomeApparel
Hoboken

EatMetal Gallery

EmailHoboken art-jewelry gallery and studioJewelrySculptureArt
Metuchen

Basecamp Studio & Gallery (Sherpa Gallery)

Heads up: Zero-commission membership model.

EmailMetuchen studio/gallery with Sherpa Gallery membership + feesArtCeramicsJewelry

Handmade in other states

California 24Colorado 5Florida 18Georgia 5Iowa 6Illinois 9Indiana 6Kentucky 6Louisiana 7Massachusetts 9Michigan 18Missouri 6North Carolina 19New York 12Ohio 15Pennsylvania 17Tennessee 7Texas 19Utah 6Virginia 11Washington 9Wisconsin 8

More in New Jersey

Consignment 11Email pitches 17Online forms 12Gift shops 18Home & design 10Jewelry 11Art & prints 18All New Jersey shops
Now Buying · the newsletter

Which independent shops are open to new brands.

New listings in New York City, Los Angeles, Chicago and 217 more cities (and the next cities as we add them), calls that just closed, vetted brand picks for buyers, and pitch notes from the other side of the counter. Sent as a short email occasionally while we're new, and growing into a weekly list as more shops and brands sign up — so we only email when there's a batch worth your inbox.