Open Shelf
New York · Handmade · 12 shops

Stores in New York That Buy Handmade

These 12 shops say they look for handmade, handcrafted or artisan-made work. 11 of them are accepting right now; the other one has a closed window or a waitlist, marked on its card. All are in New York; see all 301 nationwide.

The 12 shops

Prospect Heights · Brooklyn

The Brick Art Store

Art & gift store: artisan goods, art books, vintage records, editions by local artists, plus 'The Wall' not-for-profit gallery for young artists.

FormConsignment and/or wholesaleArtPrintsJewelry
Downtown · Buffalo

WNY Book Arts Center Artisan Shop

Nonprofit book arts center whose shop sells hand-printed posters, cards, apparel and handmade books from local printmakers and book artists.

Heads up: Focused on handmade books and printed goods.

FormConsignment. Their page doesn't state the splitPrintsCardsBooks
Elmwood / Delaware Park · Buffalo

The Shop at Buffalo AKG Art Museum

Museum shop carrying books, decor, stationery, prints and jewelry, with a group of local artisans such as Peach Pit Pottery and Linwood Candle Co.

Heads up: Museum shop.

FormEmailTheir page doesn't state terms.BooksHomeStationery
Elmwood / Buffalo State · Buffalo

The Museum Store at the Burchfield Penney

Museum store for Western New York art, with handmade jewelry, ceramics and pottery by local artisans plus Burchfield prints and cards.

Heads up: No posted maker program.

PhoneFormTheir page doesn't state terms. The store says it sells one-of-a-kind gifts and original works by local artisans.JewelryCeramicsPrints
Village of Kenmore · Kenmore

Made for Good (KVIS)

Small volunteer-run nonprofit shop on Warren Ave with one-of-a-kind jewelry, pottery, prints, candles and textiles from Western New York makers.

Heads up: Volunteer-run and small.

EmailPhonePart of each sale goes to the maker and the rest goes to the nonprofit KVIS. The split isn't statedJewelryCeramicsPrints
Multiple locations · Cheektowaga

Rustic Buffalo Artisan Market

A chain of artisan markets (Cheektowaga megastore, East Aurora, Williamsville, Elmwood Ave, Ellicottville) carrying more than 300 local Western New York artisans: farmhouse and Buffalo-themed decor, candles, soaps and gourmet foods.

Heads up: Farmhouse and Buffalo-themed decor.

FormEmailTheir page doesn't state terms.HomeGiftsJewelry
Roycroft Campus · East Aurora

Copper Shop Gallery (Roycroft Campus)

Gallery and gift shop in the historic 1902 Copper Shop on the Roycroft Campus. It carries handmade wood, metal, glass, ceramics, block prints, wearable art and jewelry from more than 100 local and national artists, in the Arts & Crafts tradition.

Heads up: No posted maker program.

EmailPhoneTheir page doesn't state terms.CeramicsJewelryPrints
Rochester

Artisans Annex

Heads up: Located inside ReHouse Architectural Salvage.

EmailCommission-based + feesGiftsArtHome
Syracuse

Wildflowers Armory

Not accepting right now. Latest November 2026-January 2027 application deadline was October 15, 2026; await next public call.

FormBooth / shelf rentalGiftsHomeJewelry
Cazenovia

Cazenovia Artisans

FormEmailPhoneJuried consignment program primarily for New York State artistsArtGifts
Jamestown

Art Cloth & Craft

EmailMost consigned workGiftsApparelJewelry
Gardiner

Little Light of Mine Village Candle

EmailPhoneIn personLocal craft consignment for handmade home décor, jewelry/accessories, artisan bath/body, art/prints, and Hudson Valley–inspired gifts. Exact split/fees not published on the Craft Consignment page — confirm with the shop. Boutique candle/craft shop — not a vendor mall.GiftsHomeJewelry

Handmade in other states

California 24Colorado 5Florida 18Georgia 5Iowa 6Illinois 9Indiana 6Kentucky 6Louisiana 7Massachusetts 9Michigan 18Missouri 6North Carolina 19New Jersey 5Ohio 15Pennsylvania 17Tennessee 7Texas 19Utah 6Virginia 11Washington 9Wisconsin 8

More in New York

Buy wholesale 12Consignment 14Email pitches 36Online forms 31Want line sheets 8Local makers 24Gift shops 34Home & design 36Jewelry 23Fashion 17Art & prints 29Beauty & wellness 9Museum shops 12Stationery & cards 11All New York shops
Now Buying · the newsletter

Which independent shops are open to new brands.

New listings in New York City, Los Angeles, Chicago and 217 more cities (and the next cities as we add them), calls that just closed, vetted brand picks for buyers, and pitch notes from the other side of the counter. Sent as a short email occasionally while we're new, and growing into a weekly list as more shops and brands sign up — so we only email when there's a batch worth your inbox.