Open Shelf
New Jersey · Gift shops · 18 shops

Gift Shops in New Jersey Accepting New Brands

These 18 gift shops publicly say they accept submissions on their own websites. All are in New Jersey; see all 775 nationwide or the New York City page or the Philadelphia page or the Poconos page or the West Windsor page.

The 18 shops

Haddon Avenue · Collingswood

Collingsweird

Apparel and gift shop where 100% of the inventory is made locally, by 50+ artists from in and around South Jersey.

Heads up: Space is limited.

EmailApparelGiftsArt
Princeton Junction

West Windsor Arts Artisan Gift Shop

Heads up: Three holiday shopping days are promotions inside the same consignment program.

EmailYear-round consignment term September 2026 to June 2027. Handmade by the artisan only + feesGiftsHomeJewelry
West Orange

West Orange Arts Council Gift Shoppe

Heads up: Commission % on inquiry.

EmailMembers-only gift shoppe showcasing one-of-a-kind local handmade art for consignment. Exact commission split not published on the Gift Shoppe page — confirm when you inquire. Boutique arts-council shop — not a vendor mall. By-appointment gallery/gift shop hours.ArtGiftsJewelry
Blairstown

Gallery 23

FormMailIn personCo-op of 30+ mostly local artists + feesArtGiftsJewelry
Red Bank

Monmouth Arts ArtSpace

Heads up: Commission % on inquiry.

FormPhoneArtist membership $40/year enables exhibit/perform opportunities at ArtSpace in Red Bank plus registry and e-blast promotion. Exact sales commission for ArtSpace retail/exhibition sales confirmed with staff + feesArtGiftsPrints
Montclair

Studio Montclair

FormEmailInclusive nonprofit artist membership organization with Montclair gallery spaces and juried/curated exhibitions + feesArtGiftsPrints
Millville

Riverfront Renaissance Center for the Arts

FormEmailMailSouth Jersey arts center with juried Artist Membership. Associate $110/year + feesArtGiftsPrints
Millville

DC Gallery & Studio

FormEmailMillville gallery/studio with recurring Holiday Shop open call for local artists & crafters on consignment, plus exhibition open calls. 2025 Holiday Shop call published Consignment Sales = 60% to artists + feesArtJewelryCeramics
Lawrence Township

Out of Step Offbeat Boutique & General Store

FormEmailMercer County boutique at Trenton Farmers Market carrying goods from ~175–300 artists, makers, and small businessesGiftsHomeApparel
Lambertville

Artists' Gallery

Heads up: Co-op membership path with published $250 + $170/mo and 100% artist sales.

EmailIn personArtist-run cooperative gallery in Lambertville + feesArtPrintsJewelry
Morristown

Just Jersey

EmailMorristown shop representing 300+ New Jersey artists, designers, specialty food makers, and small manufacturers on consignment. Vendors asked not to sell the same items within a 10-mile radius of Just Jersey. Not a fine-art galleryGiftsHomeFood
Freehold

Freehold Art Gallery

EmailIn personSecond-floor Freehold gallery featuring original paintings, sculptures, jewelry, glass, etchings, photographs, and more by emerging and established New Jersey artists. Prospective artists reviewed before invitation to participate/show. Exact sales commission not published on the For Artists page — confirm with the gallery. Boutique exhibition gallery — not a vendor mall.ArtSculptureJewelry
Maplewood

The Art Generators Gallery

FormMaplewood gallery + feesArtSculptureCeramics
Jersey City

Casa Colombo IECC Art Gallery

Heads up: Exhibition gallery with published 20% donation on sales.

EmailFormIECC / Center for the Arts at Casa Colombo offers the 2nd-floor main gallery free of charge for agreed exhibition periods. Published artist agreement + feesArtPhotographySculpture
Collingswood

Powell Lane Arts

Heads up: Split per-show, not a fixed public figure.

FormEmailCollingswood exhibition gallery with themed open calls + feesArtPhotographySculpture
Hoboken

EatMetal Gallery

EmailHoboken art-jewelry gallery and studioJewelrySculptureArt
Layton

Peters Valley Gallery

FormEmailRetail gallery at Peters Valley School of Craft + feesCeramicsTextilesWood
Metuchen

Basecamp Studio & Gallery (Sherpa Gallery)

Heads up: Zero-commission membership model.

EmailMetuchen studio/gallery with Sherpa Gallery membership + feesArtCeramicsJewelry

Gift shops in other states

Alaska 5Alabama 11Arkansas 5Arizona 21California 63Colorado 18Washington, D.C. 5Delaware 5Florida 34Georgia 19Hawaii 5Iowa 9Idaho 8Illinois 18Indiana 14Kansas 7Kentucky 12Louisiana 15Massachusetts 20Maryland 14Maine 8Michigan 32Minnesota 14Missouri 11Montana 12North Carolina 40North Dakota 6Nebraska 7New Hampshire 5New Mexico 8Nevada 10New York 34Ohio 23Oklahoma 7Oregon 14Pennsylvania 27Rhode Island 6South Carolina 5Tennessee 19Texas 48Utah 13Virginia 22Washington 28Wisconsin 24West Virginia 8

More in New Jersey

Consignment 11Email pitches 17Online forms 12Handmade 5Home & design 10Jewelry 11Art & prints 18All New Jersey shops
Now Buying · the newsletter

Which independent shops are open to new brands.

New listings in New York City, Los Angeles, Chicago and 217 more cities (and the next cities as we add them), calls that just closed, vetted brand picks for buyers, and pitch notes from the other side of the counter. Sent as a short email occasionally while we're new, and growing into a weekly list as more shops and brands sign up — so we only email when there's a batch worth your inbox.