Open Shelf
Indiana · Gift shops · 14 shops

Gift Shops in Indiana Accepting New Brands

These 14 gift shops publicly say they accept submissions on their own websites. All are in Indiana; see all 775 nationwide or the Indianapolis page or the Louisville page.

The 14 shops

Carmel Arts & Design District · Carmel

Indiana Artisan Gifts & Gallery

Nonprofit-run shop in the Carmel Arts & Design District selling art, fine craft and food from juried Indiana Artisans.

Heads up: You have to be juried in first, and fewer than 20% of applicants succeed.

FormMail samplesConsignment; $35 application fee, juried duesArtCeramicsHome
West Side · Indianapolis

Cain's Creative Chaos

DIY art studio, workshop space and local-artist gallery on Indy's west side.

Heads up: No AI art, no religious or political themes, and no mass-produced or resale items.

FormBooth / shelf rentalArtPrintsGifts
Broad Ripple · Indianapolis

Artifacts Gallery

Broad Ripple craft gallery and shop, open since 1977, carrying jewelry, ceramics, glass, wood, paper goods and wearable art from American makers.

Heads up: American artists, designers and craftspeople only.

FormWorks directly with artists; terms not statedJewelryCeramicsHome
Downtown Noblesville · Noblesville

Hamilton County Artists' Association (Birdie Gallery)

Juried nonprofit artists' association in downtown Noblesville that runs the Birdie Gallery and its gift shop.

Heads up: Juried membership is for professional artists who live in Hamilton County.

FormJuried members: $125/yr dues + volunteer hoursArtPrintsCards
Downtown Noblesville · Noblesville

NobleMade (Noblesville Creates)

Arts-council gift shop on Conner Street selling local artisan goods and Noblesville-themed gifts.

Heads up: Focused on local artisans.

EmailConsignment, 80% to you (20% commission)GiftsArt
Carmel Arts & Design District · Carmel

CCA Gallery

Indiana's original artist cooperative: more than 30 Hoosier artists in painting, pottery, glass, woodturning, textiles, jewelry and photography.

Heads up: Only artists living and creating in Indiana.

FormIn personArtist co-op: monthly dues + gallery shiftsArtCeramicsJewelry
Main Street · Zionsville

Art IN Hand Gallery

Artist-owned co-op on Zionsville's brick Main Street, open since 2000, with painting, jewelry, pottery, fused glass, woodwork and printmaking.

Heads up: The website has no membership or application details.

In personArtist-run co-op gallery; dues and commission not statedArtJewelryCeramics
Uptown New Albany · New Albany

The District Artisan Market & Patio

Uptown New Albany artisan market with handmade goods, vintage, books, craft coffee and a community patio under one roof.

Heads up: Fees and terms aren't published.

EmailPhoneMulti-vendor artisan market in a former lumber warehouse. They want vendors ready to commit to every weekend. The site doesn't state fees or the booth model.GiftsHomeJewelry
Bloomington

By Hand Gallery

Heads up: Current operator Pillar Arts explicitly handles applications.

FormBooth / shelf rentalArtCeramicsJewelry
Bloomington

Bloomington Farm Stop Craft Artisans

Heads up: Craft Artisan track only — farm co-op equity dues apply to Farm Vendors, not craft artisans.

FormEmailFood and Craft Artisan vendorsGiftsHomeJewelry
Fort Wayne

Fae's Cabinet

FormArt and oddities boutique operating primarily as consignment for artists/creators. Exact commission split is not stated on the Become a Vendor page or public FAQ. Curated one-of-a-kind / unusual handmade and curiosities focus.GiftsArtJewelry
Fort Wayne

Our Perfect Chaos Vendor Mall

Heads up: Booth-rental vendor mall (paid rental program), not open drop-off consignment.

FormPhoneBooth / shelf rentalGiftsHomeArt
South Bend

Artifact

Heads up: Booth rental + commission model.

FormEmailBooth / shelf rentalHomeArtBooks
Evansville

His N Hers Flea Market

Heads up: Flea/booth-rental model with published 10% sales commission.

FormPhoneBooth / shelf rentalGiftsHomeArt

Gift shops in other states

Alaska 5Alabama 11Arkansas 5Arizona 21California 63Colorado 18Washington, D.C. 5Delaware 5Florida 34Georgia 19Hawaii 5Iowa 9Idaho 8Illinois 18Kansas 7Kentucky 12Louisiana 15Massachusetts 20Maryland 14Maine 8Michigan 32Minnesota 14Missouri 11Montana 12North Carolina 40North Dakota 6Nebraska 7New Hampshire 5New Jersey 18New Mexico 8Nevada 10New York 34Ohio 23Oklahoma 7Oregon 14Pennsylvania 27Rhode Island 6South Carolina 5Tennessee 19Texas 48Utah 13Virginia 22Washington 28Wisconsin 24West Virginia 8

More in Indiana

Consignment 6Booth rental 5Email pitches 6Online forms 13Local makers 8Handmade 6Home & design 11Jewelry 11Fashion 8Art & prints 14All Indiana shops
Now Buying · the newsletter

Which independent shops are open to new brands.

New listings in New York City, Los Angeles, Chicago and 217 more cities (and the next cities as we add them), calls that just closed, vetted brand picks for buyers, and pitch notes from the other side of the counter. Sent as a short email occasionally while we're new, and growing into a weekly list as more shops and brands sign up — so we only email when there's a batch worth your inbox.